Bane — Complete D&D 5e Spell Guide

    By , founder of LoreifyUpdated

    Bane is a 1st-level enchantment spell that forces up to three visible creatures within 30 feet to make a Charisma saving throw or subtract 1d4 from their attack rolls and saving throws for up to 1 minute (concentration). It's a reliable debuff for early-game clerics and bards, shining against melee-heavy foes or bosses reliant on saves, but it falls off hard without upcasting due to scaling issues. It turns enemy action economy against them, since an average -2.5 penalty on every attack and save adds up. Skip it past tier 1 unless targeting save-dependent threats.

    Casting Bane this week? Loreify records your session and writes the recap, so next week you can look up what happened instead of guessing.

    Start Free Trial

    Players forget NPC names too. Loreify turns your session audio into a recap, NPC list and quotes in 5-10 minutes, and the whole table can read it.

    Try Free for 7 Days

    Stat Block

    PropertyValue
    Level1
    SchoolEnchantment
    Casting Time1 action
    Range30 feet
    ComponentsV, S, M
    MaterialA drop of blood.
    DurationUp to 1 minute
    ConcentrationYes
    RitualNo
    Save/AttackCHA
    ClassesBard, Cleric

    When NOT to Use This

    • •Enemies have advantage on Cha saves (e.g., Foresight).
    • •Party is outnumbered >3:1 and needs AoE damage now.
    • •Vs single enemies that make few attacks or saves.
    • •Concentration already tied up in Haste/Polymorph.

    Spell Slot Efficiency

    MetricAssessment
    Slot EfficiencyExcellent at 1st level (beats most debuffs), situational at 3rd+ without heavy upcasting.
    Action EconomyGood
    Opportunity CostBless (ally buff) or Command (single-target control); Bane wins vs groups.

    When worth the slot: Save-heavy bosses (dragons) or melee packs; -1d4 averages -2.5, a 12.5% swing on each d20.

    When NOT worth the slot: High-Cha immunes or when party needs raw damage (a damage spell is the better turn).

    Pro Tips

    Tip #1: Upcast to 2nd/3rd on boss +2 adds; hits 4-5 targets for ~12.5 total penalty across party threats.

    Why it works: Multi-target scaling beats single-target debuffs; averages 2.5x3=7.5 penalty at 1st level.

    This avoids the mistake of: Casting single-target, wasting upcast potential.

    Tip #2: Target the DM's 'pet' NPC with high attacks, not fodder.

    Why it works: The penalty applies to every roll, so a creature making several attacks per turn loses the most.

    This avoids the mistake of: Blanket targeting ignores DPR threats.

    Tip #3: Use with War Caster to reaction-spell on opportunity attacks.

    Why it works: Advantage on concentration saves helps keep Bane up when you're hit.

    Common Mistakes to Avoid

    Casting on high-Cha save enemies without advantage.

    Why it's bad: A strong Cha save often succeeds, wasting slot and action; that enemy ignores it for the full minute.

    Do this instead: Scout saves pre-fight or upcast Bane to add weaker targets.

    Forgetting it's concentration and overlapping with Bless.

    Why it's bad: Splits focus, drops both effects mid-fight; double opportunity cost.

    Do this instead: Pick one, or let another caster in the party run Bless.

    Targeting invisible/ethereal foes.

    Why it's bad: Must see targets; wastes action economy entirely.

    Do this instead: Use Detect Magic/See Invisibility first.

    Usage Tips

    • •Prioritize targets with multiple attacks or upcoming saves; a boss rolling 4 attacks takes the average -2.5 penalty on each one.
    • •Cast pre-combat if possible via surprise or readied action to maximize uptime.
    • •Track concentration rigorously—pair with Sentinel or Polearm Master to protect yourself.

    Rules Notes

    • •Targets must fail the initial Cha save to be affected; a target that succeeds is unaffected, and there are no repeat saves.
    • •Penalty applies only to attack rolls and saving throws, not ability checks.
    • •Upcasting adds one target per slot level above 1st; no increase in penalty strength.
    • •Bane is an enchantment but doesn't charm, so charm immunity doesn't block it RAW.

    Synergies

    • •Spirit Guardians (from another caster, since both need concentration): Debuffs enemy Wis saves against its 3d8 damage.
    • •Hold Person (from another caster): -1d4 on their Wis saves to stay paralyzed, extending lockdown.
    • •Divine Favor/Hunter's Mark from allies: Stack Bane on the boss while allies pile on damage.

    Anti-Patterns

    • •Avoid vs enemies that make few attacks or saves; the penalty has little to bite on.
    • •Don't waste on single-target when Faerie Fire hits more reliably.
    • •Skip if party has no frontline to capitalize on reduced enemy accuracy.

    Tactical Modules

    • •Boss Save Debuff — When to use: Before enemy casts a big save-or-suck like Banishment or uses lair actions.. Synergy: Combos with Cleric's Sanctuary or Aid to protect caster while enemy flubs saves.
    • •Minion Clearer — When to use: Against 3+ low-CR minions charging your backline.. Synergy: Upcast to 3rd slot hits 5 targets; follow with AoE like Burning Hands for cleanup.
    • •Legendary Resistance Bypass — When to use: Vs dragons/archmages burning LRs on other saves.. Synergy: Force repeated saves via Concentration spells, burning their 3/day pool faster.

    Countermeasures

    • •Threat: High Cha save enemies like aberrations (aboleth CR 10, Cha 18 for +4). — Response: Upcast Bane to add weaker-Cha targets.. Fallback: Switch to Faerie Fire for adv on attacks instead.
    • •Threat: Magic Resistance (advantage on saves vs spells). — Response: Check statblock first; if present, prep Bless instead.. Fallback: Position for Guiding Bolt (4d6 + next adv).
    • •Threat: Dispel Magic or Counterspell. — Response: Cast from hidden/stealthed position if Bard.. Fallback: Ready action to recast post-dispel.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is Bane good in 5e?

    Bane is good for clerics at levels 1-5, excellent vs multiattackers/boss saves with -1d4 penalty. Situational later; upcast for value. Better than Bless vs enemy groups.

    Bane vs Bless in 5e: which is better?

    Bane debuffs enemies (-1d4 attacks/saves), Bless buffs allies (+1d4). Bane better vs high-AC foes or save bosses; Bless for your low-hit party. Both concentration—pick based on side needing swing.

    Can you twin Bane in 5e?

    No, Twinned Spell requires single creature target; Bane hits up to three. Use for multi-debuff instead.

    Does Bane work on undead in 5e?

    Yes. Bane isn't a charm effect, so charm immunity doesn't stop it. Undead make the Cha save normally.

    Is Bane worth preparing as a Cleric in 5e?

    A strong prepare at low levels, especially vs melee threats and multiattackers. Swap for Spirit Guardians if AoE needed.

    Is upcasting Bane worth it in 5e?

    Yes to 3rd level for 5 targets on minion waves; beyond that, Hypnotic Pattern outperforms.

    What happens if Bane concentration is dropped in 5e?

    Ends for all targets if concentration drops. Use War Caster feat to maintain.


    Citations: api:spells/bane

    Includes SRD content per CC BY 4.0. Source: dnd5eapi.co.

    Other enchantment spells to compare with Bane: Heroism (1st level), Animal Friendship (1st level) and Calm Emotions (2nd level).

    This page includes material from the System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2.1 by Wizards of the Coast LLC, available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Loreify is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.

    Cast Bane at the table, then look back at the whole session in the recap. Notes are ready minutes after the recording stops.

    Start Free Trial