By Jordan Cole, founder of LoreifyUpdated
Acid Arrow is a 2nd-level evocation spell on the wizard list. The Player's Handbook calls it Melf's Acid Arrow; the SRD drops the name Melf. You make a ranged spell attack at a target within 90 feet. On a hit it deals 4d4 acid damage right away and 2d4 more at the end of the target's next turn. On a miss it still deals half the initial damage.
Casting Acid Arrow this week? Loreify records your session and writes the recap, so next week you can look up what happened instead of guessing.
Start Free TrialTable of Contents
- •Overview
- •Stat Block
- •When NOT to Use This
- •Spell Slot Efficiency
- •Pro Tips
- •Common Mistakes to Avoid
- •Usage Tips
- •Rules Notes
- •Synergies
- •Anti-Patterns
- •Tactical Modules
- •Countermeasures
- •Frequently Asked Questions
Players forget NPC names too. Loreify turns your session audio into a recap, NPC list and quotes in 5-10 minutes, and the whole table can read it.
Try Free for 7 DaysOverview
The verdict: it is a solid single-target damage spell, but rarely the best one. Scorching Ray usually deals more on average, and Shatter hits groups. Acid Arrow earns its place when you want damage that still lands on a miss, or a damage type few monsters resist.
If you searched for Acid Arrow in Pathfinder, note that this guide covers D&D 5e only. Pathfinder's version uses different rules.
Stat Block
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Level | 2 |
| School | Evocation |
| Casting Time | 1 action |
| Range | 90 feet |
| Components | V, S, M |
| Material | Powdered rhubarb leaf and an adder's stomach. |
| Duration | Instantaneous |
| Concentration | No |
| Ritual | No |
| Save/Attack | ranged |
| Classes | Wizard |
When NOT to Use This
- •You face a group of clustered enemies. Shatter or a 3rd-level Fireball spreads damage across several targets.
- •The target is immune to acid. Black dragons and the black pudding are two SRD examples.
- •You have Scorching Ray prepared and the target has no fire resistance. Ray usually wins on average damage.
- •You need control more than damage. Web or Hold Person may decide the fight faster.
Spell Slot Efficiency
| Metric | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Slot Efficiency | Average: about 11.5 expected damage at 2nd level in the example below |
| Action Economy | One action, no concentration |
| Opportunity Cost | Scorching Ray, Shatter, Web, and Misty Step compete for the same slot |
When worth the slot: One important target, fire-resistant enemies, or a low-AC target where most of the damage lands.
When NOT worth the slot: Groups, acid-immune creatures, or when Scorching Ray is prepared.
Pro Tips
Worked example: expected damage at 5th level
A 5th-level wizard with 18 Intelligence attacks at +7. Against an AC 15 target, the attack hits on an 8 or higher, a 65% chance.
- •A hit deals 4d4 now (average 10) plus 2d4 later (average 5), so 15 total.
- •A miss deals half of the 4d4, so about 5.
- •Expected damage: 0.65 × 15 + 0.35 × 5 = 11.5, ignoring crits.
Scorching Ray at the same bonus fires three rays of 2d6 (average 7 each). Expected damage is 3 × 0.65 × 7 = 13.65. So Scorching Ray comes out about 2 points ahead, and it can split between targets. Acid Arrow's advantage is consistency. It never deals zero damage.
Upcasting math
Each slot level above 2nd adds 1d4 to both parts of the damage. A 3rd-level slot gives 5d4 + 3d4, averaging 20 on a hit. A 9th-level slot gives 11d4 + 9d4, averaging 50. That is 5 more average damage per slot level on a hit, which is weak scaling compared to most higher-level spells.
The delayed damage forces a second concentration check
The 2d4 at the end of the target's next turn is a separate instance of damage. An enemy caster who is concentrating must make one save when the arrow hits and another when the acid burns.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Applying the delayed damage on a miss
Why it's bad: The spell is clear. A miss deals half the initial damage and nothing at the end of the next turn.
Do this instead: On a miss, roll 4d4 and halve it. Skip the 2d4.
Using it as an area spell
Why it's bad: Despite the "spray of acid" description, it hits one target only.
Do this instead: Use Shatter or Fireball for groups and save Acid Arrow for single targets.
Assuming acid is commonly resisted
Why it's bad: Acid is one of the less resisted damage types. Many fiends resist fire and cold but not acid.
Do this instead: Use it as your answer to fire-resistant or fire-immune enemies, such as devils.
Usage Tips
- •Target fire-immune enemies like devils, where Scorching Ray and Fireball fall flat.
- •Use the 90-foot range to stay well back from melee threats.
- •Pick it when you cannot afford a whiff. It always deals some damage.
- •Hit enemy concentrators. Two damage instances mean two concentration saves.
Rules Notes
- •It uses a ranged spell attack, adding your proficiency bonus and spellcasting modifier.
- •On a hit: 4d4 now and 2d4 at the end of the target's next turn.
- •On a miss: half the initial 4d4, with no delayed damage.
- •Upcasting adds 1d4 to both the initial and delayed damage per slot level above 2nd.
- •Casting it within 5 feet of a hostile creature gives you disadvantage, as with any ranged attack.
- •The spell needs no concentration. The delayed damage happens even if you cast something else.
Synergies
- •Faerie Fire or Guiding Bolt: Advantage raises the chance of the full 15 damage.
- •Hold Person: Attacks against a paralyzed creature have advantage, and a hit from within 5 feet is a critical hit. The usual disadvantage for a ranged attack within 5 feet does not apply, because a paralyzed creature is incapacitated.
- •Concentration breaking: Pairs well with an ally's damage to force repeated saves on a caster.
Anti-Patterns
- •Upcasting it into a 5th-level slot when a 5th-level spell would do more.
- •Using it on a black dragon or black pudding.
- •Casting it into heavy cover. Three-quarters cover adds +5 to the target's AC.
Tactical Modules
- •Fire-immune boss: Against a devil or fire elemental, Acid Arrow is a reliable damage option.
- •Concentration breaker: Use it on an enemy caster to force two saves over two turns.
- •Safe ranged damage: Stay at 90 feet and let the damage tick while the party holds the line.
Countermeasures
- •Threat: High AC. Response: Gain advantage first with Faerie Fire or help from a familiar. Fallback: Use a saving-throw spell instead.
- •Threat: Acid immunity. Response: Switch to a different damage type, such as Scorching Ray or Shatter.
- •Threat: Several enemies. Response: Use an area spell and save Acid Arrow for the survivor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Acid Arrow good in 5e?
It is decent. It deals about 15 damage on a hit and about 5 on a miss at 2nd level. Scorching Ray usually does a little more on average, but Acid Arrow never deals zero and uses a rarely resisted damage type.
Is Acid Arrow better than Scorching Ray in 5e?
Usually not. In the example above, Scorching Ray averages 13.65 expected damage against Acid Arrow's 11.5. Acid Arrow wins against fire-resistant targets and when you want guaranteed damage.
Does Acid Arrow work underwater in 5e?
Yes. The underwater combat rules give creatures in water resistance to fire damage, not acid. Ranged spell attacks are not ranged weapon attacks, so the weapon range penalties underwater do not apply.
Can you twin Melf's Acid Arrow in 5e?
It qualifies, since it targets one creature and has a range of 90 feet. But the spell is not on the sorcerer list. You would need another way to know it, such as a wizard multiclass.
How is Acid Arrow damage calculated in 5e?
On a hit, roll 4d4 now and 2d4 at the end of the target's next turn. On a miss, deal half of the 4d4 only. Each slot level above 2nd adds 1d4 to both rolls.
What is the best class for Acid Arrow in 5e?
Wizard, since it is a wizard spell in the SRD. Some subclasses in other books add Melf's Acid Arrow to their spell lists, so check your subclass.
Can Acid Arrow damage objects in 5e?
The spell targets "a target," not "a creature," so most tables allow objects. Your DM decides how an object's AC and hit points work.
Is upcasting Acid Arrow worth it in 5e?
Rarely. Each level adds about 5 average damage on a hit. A 3rd-level Fireball deals 8d6 (average 28) to every creature that fails its save, which is usually a better use of the slot.
Citations: api:spells/acid-arrow
Includes SRD content per CC BY 4.0. Source: dnd5eapi.co.
Other evocation spells to compare with Acid Arrow: Prayer of Healing (2nd level), Burning Hands (1st level) and Cure Wounds (1st level).
This page includes material from the System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2.1 by Wizards of the Coast LLC, available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Loreify is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.
More in Spell Guides
Scorching Ray 5e: three rays, a separate attack roll each, 2d6 fire per hit. Hit odds by AC, expected damage, upcasting, splitting targets, and 2024 notes.
Shatter 5e: 3d8 thunder in a 10-foot-radius sphere, Constitution save for half. Who gets disadvantage, object damage, save odds, and 2024 changes.
Branding Smite (D&D 5e): 2nd-level evocation spell (1 bonus action, Self, concentration). How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Moonbeam 5e: a 2nd-level druid beam that deals 2d10 radiant per trigger. When it really hits, moving it, shapechangers, and what changed in 2024.
Related Guides
Continual Flame (D&D 5e): 2nd-level evocation spell (1 action, Touch) for Cleric, Wizard. How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Darkness in D&D 5e: a 15-foot sphere that blocks darkvision. Rules, advantage math, Devil's Sight combos, and when it hurts your own party.
Gust of Wind 5e: a 60-foot line of wind that pushes creatures 15 feet on a failed Str save and doubles the cost of approaching you. Odds and 2024 changes.
Spiritual Weapon 5e: a bonus-action floating weapon that hits for 1d8 + modifier force damage each turn. Damage math, rulings, and 2024 concentration.
Cast Acid Arrow at the table, then look back at the whole session in the recap. Notes are ready minutes after the recording stops.
Start Free Trial