By Jordan Cole, founder of LoreifyUpdated
Commune is a situational but strong Cleric spell in mystery-driven campaigns, and a slot trap in hack-and-slash dungeons. As a 5th-level ritual divination, it lets you ask your deity up to three yes/no questions during a 1-minute duration—no concentration, self-only. Deities aren't omniscient, so 'unclear' is possible, and spamming it risks 25% cumulative silence per extra cast before long rest. It's great for plot intel without burning slots, but skip it if your DM runs pure combat. Spell slot economy shines as a ritual (11 minutes outside combat, no slot), giving three key facts that can stop bad plans. Opportunity cost is high in fights—a 5th-level slot could be Flame Strike (4d6 fire + 4d6 radiant, 28 avg) instead. Tip: Always ritual cast when you have the time.
Casting Commune this week? Loreify records your session and writes the recap, so next week you can look up what happened instead of guessing.
Start Free TrialPlayers forget NPC names too. Loreify turns your session audio into a recap, NPC list and quotes in 5-10 minutes, and the whole table can read it.
Try Free for 7 DaysStat Block
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Level | 5 |
| School | Divination |
| Casting Time | 1 minute |
| Range | Self |
| Components | V, S, M |
| Material | Incense and a vial of holy or unholy water. |
| Duration | 1 minute |
| Concentration | No |
| Ritual | Yes |
| Save/Attack | None |
| Classes | Cleric |
When NOT to Use This
- •Party is combat-locked—1min cast = dead Cleric vs Fireball's instant 28 avg damage.
- •DM runs linear combat dungeons—no mysteries to probe.
- •You've hit 3+ casts this rest—75% dud risk wastes time.
- •Questions too future-vague; 'Will we die?' is likely to get 'unclear'.
- •Low-RP table ignores answers—flavor dies.
- •Better options like sage hire cheaper long-term.
Spell Slot Efficiency
| Metric | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Slot Efficiency | Excellent as ritual—no slot cost outside combat, infinite casts if spaced. |
| Action Economy | Situational |
| Opportunity Cost | High: 5th slots better for Flame Strike (avg 28 damage) or Insect Plague (DoT swarm). |
When worth the slot: Emergencies needing instant intel, like mid-battle 'Is artifact here?'
When NOT worth the slot: Always ritual if possible; never in combat.
Pro Tips
Tip #1: Craft questions as binary trees: First 'Is foe in lair?', yes→'Is it alone?', no→'Is it within a mile?'
Why it works: Three yes/no questions can separate up to 8 outcomes when each one builds on the last.
This avoids the mistake of: Avoids wasting on one vague ask getting 'unclear'.
Tip #2: Ask about deity's interests first: 'Does learning this serve you?' to filter motives.
Why it works: RAW lets the GM answer with a short phrase when a yes/no would be misleading or against the deity's interests; this surfaces that early.
This avoids the mistake of: Prevents misleading yes/no contrary to alignment.
Tip #3: Stockpile materials in Bag of Holding; cast anywhere without shopping.
Why it works: You can ritual cast whenever you have 11 safe minutes, even deep in the wilds.
This avoids the mistake of: No mid-adventure material hunts.
Tip #4: Log answers in journal; patterns reveal DM plots over sessions.
Why it works: Consistent answers build a picture of the plot over time.
This avoids the mistake of: Forgetting past oracles.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Casting with a slot instead of ritual.
Why it's bad: Wastes a precious 5th-level slot (Flame Strike averages 28 per target) on info you could get for free.
Do this instead: Always ritual outside combat; save slots for healing/DPS.
Asking open-ended or future questions.
Why it's bad: 'How do we win?' isn't a yes/no question, and future questions often get 'unclear'.
Do this instead: Stick to present facts: 'Is dragon here?', 'Does door trap poison?'
Ignoring cumulative risk, spamming daily.
Why it's bad: 4th cast has 75% blank; burns trust in spell.
Do this instead: Cap at 1-2 per rest; rotate with Augury.
Poor positioning during 1min cast.
Why it's bad: Ambush kills caster, party loses healer.
Do this instead: Stealth/scout first, cast in safe zone.
Usage Tips
- •Keep incense and holy water stocked; they have no listed cost, but forgetting them strands you mid-ritual.
- •Cast pre-exploration in unknown dungeons: 'Is the boss in room A?', 'Does trap trigger on pressure?', 'Is ally betraying us?'
- •In social intrigue, verify lies: 'Does noble speak truth about artifact?' before committing.
- •Track casts per long rest; one per day is safe, second risks 25% dud.
- •Roleplay the trance: Flavor answers with deity's voice for immersion—boosts table fun.
Rules Notes
- •Answers are always correct if within the deity's knowledge; 'unclear' comes when a question lies beyond that knowledge.
- •GM may give short phrases if yes/no misleads, per RAW—great for nuanced divine interests.
- •Cumulative 25% failure per extra cast is a secret GM roll; the fourth cast has a 75% no-answer risk.
- •Ritual casting means no slot cost for Clerics, but it takes 11 minutes—position safely.
- •No limit on questions' scope beyond yes/no format; can probe secrets, traps, NPC loyalties.
Synergies
- •Pairs with Zone of Truth (2nd-level) for confirming verbal lies after yes/no intel.
- •Cleric's Channel Divinity (e.g., Knowledge Domain) enhances by revealing hidden info first.
- •Combine with Scrying (5th) for visuals, then Commune for specifics like 'Is target allied with devil?'
- •Oath of Devotion Paladins gain it as an oath spell at 17th level; pairs with high Insight for question crafting.
- •Post-Commune, Guidance (cantrip) for skill checks informed by answers.
Anti-Patterns
- •Don't spam in combat—1 minute cast gets you killed while Fireball wins fights.
- •Avoid vague questions like 'Will we succeed?'—future too unclear, wastes queries.
- •Never burn a 5th slot on it; ritual casting is free, slots better for Mass Cure Wounds.
- •Skip if DM ignores lore—'unclear' every time turns it mediocre.
Tactical Modules
- •Dungeon Intel — When to use: Before entering boss lairs or trapped wings; ask 'Is guardian immune to fire?', 'Does exit lead to surface?', 'Is treasure cursed?'. Synergy: With Detect Magic or Knowledge Domain's channel for layered scouting.
- •Intrigue Verification — When to use: Mid-RP with shady NPCs; 'Is patron planning betrayal?', 'Does relic hold demon?', 'Will alliance hold?'. Synergy: Zone of Truth follow-up turns yes/no into full confessions.
- •Puzzle Bypass — When to use: Stuck on riddles/locks; 'Does left lever open door?', 'Is password 'hope'?' (yes/no only).. Synergy: High INT ally deciphers post-Commune hints.
- •Survival Check — When to use: Wilderness perils; 'Is water safe?', 'Does beast track us?', 'Is cave infested?'. Synergy: Survivalist's expertise informed by divine nudge.
Countermeasures
- •Threat: DM gives all 'unclear' answers — Response: Rephrase to basics: Swap 'Where is artifact?' for 'Is artifact in city?'; probe step-by-step.. Fallback: Fall to Augury for future glimpses or hire sage (safer gold sink).
- •Threat: Interrupted ritual cast — Response: Position in cover before you start. Fallback: If your concentration breaks while casting, the spell fails without using a slot; Dodge and recast post-combat.
- •Threat: Cumulative failure roll blanks you — Response: One cast per long rest max; track personally.. Fallback: Use Divination (4th) as backup; it tracks its own separate cumulative risk.
- •Threat: Party rushes without waiting — Response: Communicate value: 'This could save our lives'—show an early win.. Fallback: Solo cast during short rest.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Commune good in 5e?
Situational excellent for Clerics in plot-heavy games—free ritual intel beats sages. Poor in combat slogs; ritual cast or skip. Always prepare if mysteries abound.
Commune vs Augury in 5e: which is better?
Commune > Augury for present facts (3 yes/no vs 1 omen); Augury better for futures/plans. Both rituals, but Commune's scope wins intrigue.
Does Commune use a spell slot in 5e?
No if ritual cast by Cleric—free outside combat. Slots only for instant needs, but rare.
What happens if you cast Commune multiple times in 5e?
25% cumulative no-answer per extra before long rest (secret GM roll). Stick to 1/day safe.
What are the best Commune questions in 5e?
Binary facts: 'Is boss alive?', 'Trap in room?', 'NPC lies?'. Avoid future or vague questions to reduce 'unclear' answers.
Can Commune detect lies in 5e?
Yes, indirectly: 'Does witness tell truth about murder?'. Follow with Zone of Truth.
Can you ritual cast Commune in 5e?
Yes. Clerics can cast it as a ritual in 11 minutes (1 minute plus 10), with no slot. Stock materials.
Commune vs Scrying in 5e: which should you use?
Commune for quick yes/no (ritual free); Scrying for visuals (slot-heavy). Combo: Scry then Commune specifics.
Citations: api:spells/commune
Includes SRD content per CC BY 4.0. Source: dnd5eapi.co.
Other divination spells to compare with Commune: Divination (4th level), Arcane Eye (4th level) and Clairvoyance (3rd level).
This page includes material from the System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2.1 by Wizards of the Coast LLC, available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Loreify is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.
More in Spell Guides
Commune With Nature (D&D 5e): 5th-level divination spell (1 minute, Self) for Druid, Ranger. How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Contact Other Plane (D&D 5e): 5th-level divination spell (1 minute, Self) for Warlock, Wizard. How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Scrying 5e: spy on a creature anywhere on your plane. Wisdom save modifier table (+5 to −10), save odds vs real monsters, sensor rules, and 2024 changes.
Contagion (D&D 5e): 5th-level necromancy spell (1 action, Touch) for Cleric, Druid. How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Related Guides
Augury (D&D 5e): 2nd-level divination spell (1 minute, Self) for Cleric. How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Detect Poison and Disease (D&D 5e): 1st-level divination spell (1 action, Self, concentration). How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Detect Magic (D&D 5e): 1st-level divination spell (1 action, Self, concentration). How it works, best uses and mistakes to avoid.
Raise Dead 5e: revive a creature dead up to 10 days for a 500 gp diamond. The −4 penalty, curses, undead limits, vs Revivify, and 2024 changes.
Cast Commune at the table, then look back at the whole session in the recap. Notes are ready minutes after the recording stops.
Start Free Trial